The Antitypical Day of Atonement and Current SDA Discussions on Last Generation Theology

Click to go to our Home Page


 

Dear Reader,

There is much discussion of late involving the issue of Last Generation Theology in connection with the SDA Questions on Doctrine 50th Anniversary Conference. In view of the fact that we are living in the antitypical Day of Atonement, in which all sin was to be put from the camp of Israel, I believe the following study is apropos and needed at this time. A denial of Last Generation Theology, is a denial of the Antitypical Day of Atonement and the Investigative Judgment, and the fact that our sins must go into judgment beforehand:

 

1Ti 5:24 Some men's sins are open beforehand, going before to judgment; and some [men] they follow after.

 

The following treatise was presented on an SDA Internet forum by a man named Wally. I felt it to be so thorough and representative of such serious truth that I am publishing it for all to read. Ron

 

***

 

I believe that:

(a) "Heaven itself" is not the sanctuary ; rather the sanctuary is
in "heaven itself" .

(b) Dan . 9 :24, while referring primarily
an application to us today .

(c) Dan . 8:14 is the same as Malachi
not just a doctrine but is to be a special cleansing experience
in the lives of God's people .

(d) Lev . 16 :30 is referring to the
people on the day of atonement .

(e) This special cleansing is made possible by Christ making a
special, final atonement in the most holy place of the
sanctuary (EW 251, 253) .
This special atonement blots out sins from the minds of God's
people as well as in the records of heaven (PP 202, 358 ; GC
620 ; 5T 472-5) .

(g) This special experience of the blotting out of sins brings
perfecting latter rain to the church (Acts 3 :19 RV ; TM 506) .

(h) Without this final atonement of the most holy place it would
be impossible to attain to the finality of moral perfection.

(i) Men in this last generation must receive this final atonement
in order to be saved, i .e ., if they are to be translated .

(j) The sealing of the living (Rev . 7 :2, 3) takes place prior to
the close of probation (1SM 66) .

(k) The door of mercy will close to those who have known the truth
before it closes to those who have not known the truth (9T 97) .
God's people will attain to sinless perfection of character before the close of probation (GC 623).

In other wards God's people must gather to the
sanctuary by faith in accordance with the requirements of the antitypical
day of atonement (Joel 2 :15-17) . When they do so, Christ
will blot out their sins and give them the latter rain (Joel 2 :18-28 ;
Acts 3 :19 RV) . Those who gather at the sanctuary for this special
work will receive the great blessing of the day of atonement ; those
who fail to respond will be "cut off" from Israel (EW 270-1) .
The issue is a very fundamental one . Will we co-operate with our
High Priest in His special and final work for us, or will we refuse
to enter into this work? The simple realisation of what the day
of atonement means is beginning to awaken God's people in different part of the world.


Conclusion

1 .  Acts 3 :19 has an eschatological meaning .

"Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord;"
 
2.   In its eschatological meaning it points us to the judgment in the
most holy place .
 
3.   Our preparation for the blotting out of sin in the judgment is to
repent and to be converted . Any man who is converted and remains in
a state of conversion will stand in the judgment and receive the blotting
out of sins.
 
4.   Our preparation for the latter rain is to repent and to be converted,
and those who remain converted will receive the perfecting latter rain .
 
5.   Acts 3 :19 certainly shows that the latter rain is not given to
prepare for the judgment. Along with the blotting out of sins, it is the
blessing of the judgment. The Spirit of Prophecy says that the latter
rain empowers the saints to give the loud cry, fits them to live through
the time of trouble, and prepares them for the Advent of Christ (Early
Writings, . 71, 85, 86 ; Testimonies to Ministers, . 506).

But nowhere does it suggest that the latter rain prepares us for the judgment .
Those who expect the latter rain to prepare them for the judgment wait
in vain . Rather, the latter rain is the blessing of the judgment (Joel 2 ;
Testimonies, Vol . 1, . 179-183 ; Vol . 5, . 473-475) .
 
6.   Since the blotting out of sins is inseparably linked to the latter
rain, and since the latter rain is a great final work of grace in the lives
of the saints (Testimonies to Ministers, . 506), it is forever certain
that the blotting out of sins is a mighty experience . It is more than a
judicial cleansing of a record of sin in heaven . It will blot out the
record of sin from the minds of the saints (Great Controversy, . 670;
Patriarchs and Prophets, . 538, 202 ; Spiritual Gifts, Vol. 3, . 135;
Hebrews 10:1-31 ; Jeremiah 50 :20).
 
7.   John the Revelator calls this final work of grace the seal of the
living God (Revelation 7:2-4) . It will be the saints' protection for the
time when they must live without a Mediator in the heavenly sanctuary .
 
8.   As surely as we live in the hour when His judgment is come (Revelation
14 :7), just so surely do we live in the time when Jesus is waiting
to blot out our sins and to give us the latter rain . The door to the most
holy place is open (Revelation 3:8) ; we are invited to enter the sanctuary
by faith to claim the benefit of His judgment ministration . What
is holding  up the reception of these mighty blessings upon the church?
Just as soon as we thoroughly repent and turn to God, sending all
our sins beforehand to the judgment, the High Priest can blot out our sins
and give us the latter rain . In Acts 3 :19 the purpose clause introduced
by "hop'-oce" an implies suddenness. When God's people make the needful
preparation, the latter rain will come suddenly . Our High Priest will
come suddenly with the blessing of the final atonement (Malachi 3:1-3) .
The Lord will come suddenly to reveal the closing glory of the gospel
dispensation (Isaiah 40 :2-9) . The High Priest will not delay when the
congregation repents and turns to Him with all their heart (Joel 2 :
15-28). Christ will answer suddenly with the abundant showers of the
latter rain.

 

Below are the same points as above but with more details and references:

 

1.   Acts 3 :19 has an eschatological meaning .

 

 Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord;

 

 

2.   In its eschatological meaning it points us to the judgment in the

most holy place .

 

 

Therefore, because of (1) hidden sinfulness and (2) the

record of sin, sinless perfection of character is not attained in

what we might call "the daily" experience - to use the symbolism

of the sanctuary .

Now, if perfection is not experienced at conversion, nor

in that daily walk of being sanctified, when and where is it

found?

 

Perfection-in the Most Holy Place

The third angel, whose message is to perfect a people for

the great day of God, points to the most holy place :

"The third angel closes his message thus : `Here is the patience

of the saints : here are they that keep the commandments of God,

and the fanth of Jesus.' As he repeated these words, he pointed to

the heavenly sanctuary . The minds of all who embrace this message

are directed to the most holy place, . . . I saw the third angel pointing

upward. . . . to the holiest of the heavenly sanctuary . . . the third

angel was pointing them to the most holy place, . . ."-Early Writings,

pp. 254-256.

It is evident, therefore, that we shall find the experience

which the third angel is calling for, if we will direct our

minds by faith to the most holy place . What is this work in

the most holy place of the sanctuary that will perfect the saints?

"As the priest entered the most holy once a year to cleanse the

earthly sanctuary, so Jesus entered the most holy of the heavenly,

at the end of the 2300 days of Daniel 8, in 1844, to make a final

atonement for all who could be benefited by His mediation, and

thus to cleanse the sanctuary."-Ibid., p . 253 .

 

 

3.   Our preparation for the blotting out of sin in the judgment is to

repent and to be converted . Any man who is converted and remains in

a state of conversion will stand in the judgment and receive the blotting

out of sins.

 

 

Prescott:

There is a difference between the gospel being preached for the forgiveness of sins and the gospel being preached for the blotting out of sin. Always, and today, there is abundant provision for the forgiveness of sins. In our generation comes the provision for the blotting out of sin. And the blotting out of sin is what will prepare the way for the coming of the Lord; and the blotting out of sin is the ministry of our High Priest in in the most holy place of the heavenly sanctuary..

 

But absolute sinless perfection is impossible without the blotting out of sins and the

perfecting latter rain . (Acts 3 :19 RV ; 5T 475 ; TM 506 ; 4T 367) .

It is the "cleansing of the sanctuary" (final atonement) which

finishes the mystery of God (Dan . 8 :14 ; Rev . 10 :6, 7) .

Did the gospel preaching in past ages develop a church without spot

or wrinkle, a church appearing in "untainted purity and spotless

perfection," a church fully prepared for translation? The answer

is no! Only after the ministry of Jesus in the most holy place

"will the followers of Christ be ready for His appearing ." GC 425 .

 

 

By growing daily in the divine

life, he will not attain to the full stature of a perfect man in

Christ until his probation ceases ." 4T 367 .

 

Ellen G. White

As Quoted In Sanctuary

Institute Syllabus No. 3

"The righteous [in the time of trouble] will not cease their

earnest agonizing cries for deliverance . They cannot bring to mind

any particular sins, but in their whole life they can see but little

good. Their sins had gone beforehand to judgment, and pardon

had been written . Their sins had been borne away into the land

of forgetfulness, and they could not bring them to remembrance ."

-Spiritual Gifts, Vol. 3, . 135 .

" . . while they have a deep sense of their unworthiness, they

will have no concealed wrongs to reveal . Their sins will have been

blotted out by the atoning blood of Christ, and they cannot bring

them to remembrance" Patriarchs and Prophets, . 202 .

". . . in the final atonement the sins of the truly penitent are to

be blotted from the records of heaven, no more to'be remembered

or come into mind, . . ."-Ibid., . 358.

"But while they have a deep sense of their unworthiness, they

have no concealed wrongs to reveal . Their sins have gone beforehand

to judgment, and have been blotted out, and they cannot

bring them to remembrance ."-Great Controversy, . 620.

 

 

Yet the work of grace is not completed. The latter

rain, which is the baptism of divine love in all its fullness, is needed to

bring the believer to perfection (cf. Testimonies to Ministers, . 506).

It is the baptism of divine love in the latter rain that perfects the conscience,

seals the believer, and blots out sin. Those who have this final

covering will be able to live in the sight of a holy God without a mediator

during the period of the seven last plagues. Those without the seal of

God will be tormented day and night by their own consciences in the

presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb (Revelation

14:10, 11). How thankful we should be that God has promised the

perfecting latter rain to prepare a people for the great day of God (cf .

Early Writings, . 71 ; Testimonies to Ministers, . 506) .

 

"Not even by a thought could our Saviour be brought to yield to the

power of temptation . . . . This is the condition in which those must be

found who shall stand in the time of trouble ."-Great Controversy, 623.

 

Not even by a thought will the sealed saints defile their minds .

Love thinks no evil .

 

"Their sins have gone beforehand to judgment, and have been blotted

out ; and they cannot bring them to remembrance."-Ibid., . 620.

 

This does not mean an amnesia to past events, but as the context of the

statement shows, as God's people review the events of their lives, they

have no more conscience of sins. They cannot bring their past sins

(their wrong thoughts and feelings) to remembrance . Love thinks no

evil. Those who are made perfect in love by the anointing of the latter

rain will not bring to mind any past thought or feeling of sin . This is

what our High Priest promises to do for us while He ministers in the

most holy lace :

"For on that day shall the priest make an atonement for you,

to cleanse you, that ye may be clean from all your sins before

the Lord" (Leviticus 16 :30).

 

When God indeed has such a people, who are settled in their faith

in Him, who will no longer think evil of Him, then He will rejoice over a

people who will be like Him. Sin will have been blotted out of their

hearts' experience. Such saints will never sin again, for they would not

distrust God sufficiently to sin again. Such people will not fail in the

great day of test and trial, for love never faileth . The thoughts and

feelings of sin, so long associated with the events of life, will not come

into mind. This is the experience that God has for His children in the

cleansing of the sanctuary brought to view in Daniel 8 :14. This is what

the apostle Peter calls the blotting out of sins . This is what the apostle

Paul calls the perfecting of the conscience. This is what John the beloved

calls being made perfect in the love which casts out all doubt and fear .

This is what the Revelator calls the seal of the living God . This is what

the prophet Joel calls the latter rain . This is what Ellen G . White calls

the final atonement . It is the everlasting gospel, fully unfolded, fully

experienced by those who live in this hour of His judgment.

 

 

4.   Our preparation for the latter rain is to repent and to be converted,

and those who remain converted will receive the perfecting latter rain .

 

5.   Acts 3 :19 certainly shows that the latter rain is not given to

prepare for the judgment. Along with the blotting out of sins, it is the

blessing of the judgment. The Spirit of Prophecy says that the latter

rain empowers the saints to give the loud cry, fits them to live through

the time of trouble, and prepares them for the Advent of Christ (Early

Writings, . 71, 85, 86 ; Testimonies to Ministers, . 506).

But nowhere does it suggest that the latter rain prepares us for the judgment .

Those who expect the latter rain to prepare them for the judgment wait

in vain . Rather, the latter rain is the blessing of the judgment (Joel 2 ;

Testimonies, Vol . 1, . 179-183 ; Vol . 5, . 473-475) .

 

Gathering at the Sanctuary Before the Decree

It will be too late for us to arise with our empty vessels

and lamps when the great Sabbath test comes, and with it the

judgment of the living and latter rain . The time of the loud

cry will not be a time of mercy for those who have had an

opportunity to know what is truth . It will be a time of mercy

for those only who have never heard or rejected the third

angel's message (see Early Writings, p. 278 ;.S.D.A. Bible Commentary,

Vol. 7, p . 979) .

 

So God is telling us that the antitypical

day of atonement gathering must take place in the church just

before the decree goes forth .

 

We have been warned many times in the Spirit of Proph-

-26-

ecy that those who have not made the needful preparation

will not be able to receive the latter rain . It will then be too

late (see Early Writings, pp. 71, 270, 271 ; Testimonies to

Ministers, pp. 506, 507) . The judgment of the living will have

found them destitute of the wedding garment ; they will have

appeared in the shame of their own nakedness in the great

testing time ; and they will have been shaken out of the Lamb's

book of life . In the darkness of eternal separation from God,

they will neither discern nor recognize the latter rain, even

though it might be falling all around them (see Testimonies

to Ministers,, p. 507) . Oh, who can afford to be passed by

when the Holy Spirit, represented by the man with the writer's

inkhorn, will pass through the church with the seal of God?

To be passed by then will be to be passed by forever.

 

 

6.   Since the blotting out of sins is inseparably linked to the latter

rain, and since the latter rain is a great final work of grace in the lives

of the saints (Testimonies to Ministers, . 506), it is forever certain

that the blotting out of sins is a mighty experience . It is more than a

judicial cleansing of a record of sin in heaven . It will blot out the

record of sin from the minds of the saints (Great Controversy, . 670;

Patriarchs and Pro hets, . 538, 202 ; S iritual Gifts, Vol. 3, . 135;

Hebrews 10:1-31 ; Jeremiah 50 :20).

 

7.   John the Revelator calls this final work of grace the seal of the

living God (Revelation 7:2-4) . It will be the saints' protection for the

time when they must live without a Mediator in the heavenly sanctuary .

 

8.    As surely as we live in the hour when His judgment is come (Revelation

14 :7), just so surely do we live in the time when Jesus is waiting

to blot out our sins and to give us the latter rain . The door to the most

holy place is open (Revelation 3:8) ; we are invited to enter the sanctuary

by faith to claim the benefit of His judgment ministration . What

is holding us from the reception of these mighty blessings upon the church?

Just as soon as we thoroughly repent and turn to God, sending all

our sins beforehand to the judgment, the High Priest can blot out our sins

and give us the latter rain . In Acts 3 :19 the purpose clause introduced

by ho -6s an implies suddenness. When God's people make the needful

preparation, the latter rain will come suddenly . Our High Priest will

come suddenly with the blessing of the final atonement (Malachi 3:1-3) .

The Lord will come suddenly to reveal the closing glory of the gospel

dispensation (Isaiah 40 :2-9) . The High Priest will not delay when the

congregation repents and turns to Him with all their heart (Joel 2 :

15-28). Christ will answer suddenly with the abundant showers of the

latter rain . What a promise! What a warning to be ready! Oh, for

repentant hearts and converted lives in readiness for His sudden coming

in judgment! The end of all things is surely upon us. To the sanctuary,

0 Israel (Joel 2 :15-17)!

 

 

The Latter Rain

It is important that we notice the relationship of the latter

rain to this work of final atonement or blotting out of sins .

After Joel calls God's people to afflict their souls at the sanctuary,

he promises that God will "restore the years that the

locust hath eaten"-the evil ravages of sin upon the soul-by

sending' the latter rain to His people (Joel 2 :23-28) . Peter,

commenting upon this prophecy, says, "Repent ye therefore, and

be converted, that your sins may be blotted out, when the times

of refreshing shall come from the presence of the Lord" (Acts

3 :19) . It is the latter rain which blots out sin from the experience

of Israel (see also Isa. 4 :2-5) .

Christ ministers in the heavenly temple, but the Spirit

ministers in the soul temple, applying the benefits of Christ's

work to the individual soul who connects with that ministry .

Thus when Christ removes the record of sin from the books of

heaven, the Spirit does the corresponding work in the soul temple.

So too, when Christ retains the name in the book of life

after that candidate is judged, the Holy Spirit seals the mind so

that it retains the moral image of God (see Eph . 4 :30 ; Testimonies,

Vol. 3, p. 267) . That it is the baptism of the latter

rain which completes this work of grace in the life is made clear

by the following statement :

"The latter rain, falling near the close of the season, ripens the

grain and prepares it for the sickle . . . . The ripening of the grain

represents the completion of the work of God's grace in the soul .

By the power of the Holy Spirit the moral image of God is to be

perfected in the character . We are to be wholly transformed into the

likeness of Christ . . . . Unless the early showers have done their

work, the latter rain can bring no seed to perfection ."-Testimonies

to Ministers, p. 506. (see also Early Writings, p . 271) .

The latter rain, therefore, is the blessing of the most holy

place, and will not come until we make the necessary preparation,

enter the judgment of the living, and receive the final

atonement. Then sins are blotted out "when the times of refreshing . . . come from the presence of the Lord" (Acts 3 :19) .

Those who receive the seal of God through the anointing of the

Spirit will herald the final message of mercy in the loud cry of

the third angel's message . (This is made plain in some of the

great prophecies of the Bible . Compare Isa . 44 :22, 23 with

55 :5 ; 62 :2, 3 ; Rev. 3 :12 ; 14 :1 ; and Ezek. 43 :1-3 with Rev .

7 :2 ; 18 :1) . Those converted during the loud cry will also

enter the judgment of the living and receive the blotting out

of sins and sealing through the baptism of the latter rain . When

the last soul has been sealed, probation will close for all . The

speed with which the work will close when these times of refreshing

come defies any adequate description . God is simply

waiting for His people to awake to the realities of the great

day of atonement .

 

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 

 

4. The Latter Rain, Loud Cry

After the gathering at the sanctuary in affliction of soul

comes the latter rain . This is very clearly presented in the

second chapter of Joel, and also in Ellen G . White's comments

in Testimonies, Vol. 1, pp. 179-183 . The final outpouring of

the Spirit on the church is brought to view in Revelation 18 : 1 .

Another mighty angel is brought to view as descending to

the earth to unite his voice with the third angel . Thus the third

message is given with the "loud cry," the final warning to be

given to all the world . All are thereby brought to take their

stand and then probation closes for all . The latter rain also

perfects the saints, enabling them to stand during the time of

the seven last plagues without a Mediator in the sanctuary, and

then to meet the Son of man as He comes in power and great

glory.